Player ratings Swindon at home

  • aberdeenblue28
  • aberdeenblue28's Avatar Topic Author
  • Offline
  • Youth Team Player
  • Youth Team Player
More
08 Feb 2020 22:09 #1 by aberdeenblue28
Player ratings Swindon at home was created by aberdeenblue28
I wasn’t there to today so can someone fill me in?

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
08 Feb 2020 22:28 #2 by carlisleunited
Replied by carlisleunited on topic Player ratings Swindon at home
Collin 7
Jones 7
Webster 7.5
Hayden 7
Anderton 7
Watt 7
Jones 7
Guy 7
Thomas 7
Alessandra 7
Mckirdy 7

Patrick 7
Bridge 7
Charters 7

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
08 Feb 2020 22:40 #3 by seesaw50
Replied by seesaw50 on topic Player ratings Swindon at home
Interested why Webster gets .5 more than Hayden who scored and got MOM

To have been born Cumbrian
is to have won the lottery of life !

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
08 Feb 2020 22:44 #4 by carlisleunited
Replied by carlisleunited on topic Player ratings Swindon at home
Because I thought he did better overall than Hayden.

Instead of criticising, just post your ratings.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
08 Feb 2020 22:50 #5 by Mullen103
Replied by Mullen103 on topic Player ratings Swindon at home
On Ifollow

Collin 5
Jones 6
Webster 7
Hayden 7
Anderton 6
Watt 7
Jones 5
Guy 6
Thomas 6
Alessandra 6
Mckirdy 4 - it seems a little harsh but seemed injured after a bad tackle.

Patrick 6
Bridge 6
Charters 6

Beech 9 - warming to him a lot, no tippy tappy nonsense just simple. Any danger clear it and hoof upfield.

At least we’re not Stockport

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
08 Feb 2020 22:51 #6 by cousinscotty
Replied by cousinscotty on topic Player ratings Swindon at home
Don't tend to do ratings because my personal bias would creep in (Collin would never get more than 5 from me, for instance). Hayden and Webster were immense - in fact the back four were excellent but they needed to be against Swindon. I can see why they score so many goals - they're all trying to score whereas we tend to attack in ones and twos. Watt lost his man on a few occasions which could have cost us but I have to remember that he is still very young. Alessandra and Patrick will improve once they get full match fitness and Guy grew in to the game. Thomas stayed too much on the byline for me although he was being doubled up on. Mike Jones is a joy to watch.

But then there's McKirdy... Let's be kind and say it wasn't his game to shine in today.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
08 Feb 2020 22:53 #7 by Seekaye
Replied by Seekaye on topic Player ratings Swindon at home
Collin 7
Jones 7
Webster 7
Hayden 8
Anderton 6
Watt 7
Jones 7
Guy 6
Thomas 7
Alessandra 6
Mckirdy 6

Patrick 6
Bridge 7
Charters 6

They kicked Mckirdy out of the game with two terrible tackles, one of which was a potential red and wasn’t given as a free kick despite the ref being 5 yards away looking straight at it. Tactical fouling by them also went unpunished. Very poor refereeing

I though the defence was excellent and Collin made two saves and looked very solid so hopefully he’s over his blip.

Fair play to Beech, he’s got us playing so much better than before, working hard and showing some quality.

A good point but I wasn’t a fan of the cheering immediately at the final whistle like we’d done ever so well to get a point from the mighty Swindon.
The following user(s) Liked this post:: seesaw50

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
08 Feb 2020 22:55 #8 by CCU
Replied by CCU on topic Player ratings Swindon at home

aberdeenblue28 wrote: I wasn’t there to today so can someone fill me in?


You want battered for not going?

Random request...

;)

Win or Lose, Up The Blues!
The following user(s) Liked this post:: Wukkie, lbtufty, ParcelPete, cufcaussiebranch, cufcmike

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • Bluedazblue
  • Away
  • Youth Team Player
  • Youth Team Player
More
08 Feb 2020 23:40 #9 by Bluedazblue
Replied by Bluedazblue on topic Player ratings Swindon at home

Seekaye wrote: Collin 7
Jones 7
Webster 7
Hayden 8
Anderton 6
Watt 7
Jones 7
Guy 6
Thomas 7
Alessandra 6
Mckirdy 6

Patrick 6
Bridge 7
Charters 6

They kicked Mckirdy out of the game with two terrible tackles, one of which was a potential red and wasn’t given as a free kick despite the ref being 5 yards away looking straight at it. Tactical fouling by them also went unpunished. Very poor refereeing

I though the defence was excellent and Collin made two saves and looked very solid so hopefully he’s over his blip.

Fair play to Beech, he’s got us playing so much better than before, working hard and showing some quality.

A good point but I wasn’t a fan of the cheering immediately at the final whistle like we’d done ever so well to get a point from the mighty Swindon.


I totally agree with you about the first foul on McKirdy, but I think the referee was on the wrong side of the play to give a judgement. The linesman on the East Stand side was further away, but was perfectly positioned to see that the tackle was high and dangerous.
The following user(s) Liked this post:: seesaw50

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
08 Feb 2020 23:42 #10 by Graemehud
Replied by Graemehud on topic Player ratings Swindon at home
First game for me at BP this season. At Swindon they were a well drilled cynical team, poor defensively but strong, hard and dirty in midfield and good in attack.
They were the same today. The mistake they made was to move Yates on the wing to accommodate Hopeless.
Anyway, my ratings:

Colin 6.5 always feel he has a rick in him this season. Doesn’t distribute quickly enough for me. The soft goal not down to him.
G. Jones 6 given the runaround in the first half (possibly because Thomas was off the boil leaving him exposed) but fought back into the game.
Hayden 7.5 got MOM and scored a cracking header. Just getting better every game
Webster 7.5 could have got MOM, dominant against the leagues top scorers. He is now the player we thought we signed.
Anderton 7 he is a proper full back. Quality player did nothing wrong, I like him
Watt 7 - I make no bones about this lad for his age he is quality, wish he was ours permanently
M Jones - 7.5 does what he does very well. Has started to move the ball forward a lot quicker than he used to.
Guy 7.5 - another that could have been MOM today. None stop all action midfielder, added some guts in that area, expect more from him once bedded in
Thomas 6 - an off day for me from some recent games that I have watched him but if he was more consistent he wouldn’t be at CU
Alessandra 7 - works hard for the team, started in wrong position for me, looked more effective when Patrick came on
McKirdy 7 - kicked off the park by cynical dirty, some say professional fouls. Ref gave no protection. He had two two footed hits on him and nothing given
Patrick 7 - strong lad, didn’t seem phased by some of the nudges in the back and cynicism from their defenders. One for the future.
Bridge - grudging 6, he actually made a couple of tackles but will never win me round
Charters - not on long enough but got stuck in

Beech 8 - looking forward to next season with him in charge

Ref - 4 poor, didn’t pull out a card as far as I saw, should have been a few for their left back alone

Enjoyed the game, wrong for anyone to say it was a bore draw. You have to remember that they are the runaway league leaders and we comfortably contained them in poor conditions.
Hope was a prick over-celebrating their goal like he was top dog that got them to the top of the league. The boos were acceptable. Pleased that he has gone.
The following user(s) Liked this post:: seesaw50, lbtufty, Almost Bertie

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
09 Feb 2020 01:37 #11 by digger
Replied by digger on topic Player ratings Swindon at home
Disregarding the ratings ,I thought the linesman on the east stand side was a joke he wrongly flagged Mckirdy offside when he had a great chance to score an equaliser and the referee wasn’t much better the sooner we can get out of this shit league can’t come soon enough ,fingers very much crossed.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
09 Feb 2020 08:08 #12 by JoziBlue
Replied by JoziBlue on topic Player ratings Swindon at home
Watched on iFollow from an even stormiest Johannesburg.

Collin - 6 - One really good reaction save in the second half. Kicking remains really poor. Got to be a replacement solution found for him for next season.

G. Jones and Anderson - 7 - As Lummy said, full-backs are great when you don’t have to mention them. These two are such an improvement on Elliot and Iredale. Defensively sound and as we get better I’m hoping they can start getting forward more too.

Webster - 7.5 - Must have been something in his head before Christmas. All those fresh air kicks and missed headers have gone. Now just a solid and sensible defender.

Hayden - 8 - I said after his first game that he reminded me of Deano, and he is young enough and talented enough to turn into Stephane. Good header for the goal.

Watt - 6.5 - Yet to be totally convinced by him. Obviously struggling with the heavy pitches and physicality of League 2 football. Looks like he has enough in him to come good though.

M. Jones - 7 - Right place, right time. Good player at our level.

Guy - 7 - Somehow seemed to head it backwards from 6 yards out but great that he got there in the first place. Going to be a very good player for us when he settles.

McKirdy and Thomas - 6 - With the weather as it was it was never a game for them yesterday. Teams obviously fear them as the doubling up and terrible tackling on McKirdy shows. Would love to have them both back next season.

Alessandra - 6 - Solid but unspectacular. No pace at all. Now we have Patrick and Kayode I don’t see Alessandra getting too much game time.

Patrick - 7 - Tough in that wind but he put himself about, won some headers and kept trying. Looks a good acquisition.

Bridge - 5 - Was he sporting a top-knot yesterday. That is enough reason to let him go at the end of the season as well as the fact that he offers nothing on the pitch.

Charters - 6 - Great to see another young lad coming through. Obviously not scared of the game or the occasion.
The following user(s) Liked this post:: lbtufty

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
09 Feb 2020 08:44 #13 by ParcelPete
Replied by ParcelPete on topic Player ratings Swindon at home

CCU wrote:

aberdeenblue28 wrote: I wasn’t there to today so can someone fill me in?


You want battered for not going?

Random request...

;)


Craig David could.
The following user(s) Liked this post:: CCU

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
09 Feb 2020 08:46 #14 by 1954Blue
Replied by 1954Blue on topic Player ratings Swindon at home
Colin 6 a couple of good reaction saves which kept us in it. Kicking not his strong point so always a worry on windy days
G. Jones 6 struggled in 1st half but did much better in the 2nd
Hayden 8 superb defensively and scoring the goal an added bonus
Webster 7 pleasing the way he has turned it round and a solid display
Anderton 7 a solid, professional performance
Watt 7 displays a confidence and maturity beyond his years and should only get better
M Jones - 7 reliable as ever and has become more effective in attack playing a bit further forward
Guy 7 looks another good acquisition, played well box to box and linked up well with M Jones
Thomas 6 not as involved as much as lately but well marked throughout
Alessandra 6 didn't really get into it when we played the long ball in the first half
McKirdy 6 difficult to judge at times if he is really badly injured ( the boy who cried wolf springs to mind ) but looked a bad tackle on him on the half way line that was at least a yellow card

Patrick 7 encouraging performance, not easily knocked off the ball and worked tirelessly as first line of defence
Bridge 6 actually seemed interested and got involved from the off

Ludicrous that not one of their players was booked. Constant cynical fouling by Swindon that the ref did nothing about

A really encouraging performance all round
The following user(s) Liked this post:: lbtufty

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • thetashkentterror
  • Offline
  • Bench Warmer
  • Bench Warmer
More
09 Feb 2020 10:03 #15 by thetashkentterror
Replied by thetashkentterror on topic Player ratings Swindon at home
McKirdy should have been booked for re-entering the field of play without the referee's permission.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
09 Feb 2020 10:37 #16 by CUFC52
Replied by CUFC52 on topic Player ratings Swindon at home
Never going to get a foul in Anderton for the goal he started shirt pulling/ pushing first.

Colin-6 sketchy at coming for crosses, goal kicks are awful.

G Jones - 8 let’s give him some credit out, him and Anderton have pocketed (Yates and Hope - Jerry is the 4th highest scorer in the leauge)

Hayden -8 is their anything this lad won’t head ? Pleasing thing is he seems to be learning too, seems to of cut out the rash challenges.

Webster 7.5 would of been an 8 if not for his part in the goal, once the man wins it v Anderton - Byron has switched off (again) and left his man, other than that his best performance at Carlisle.

Anderton- 7 imo never a foul for their goal, his passing was very wasteful first 30, but he’s a marked improvement on Ierdale.

Watt - 6.5 the fact you could argue that was his worst performance for Carlisle, shows the lads ability. Grew into the game but was off the pace early on.

M Jones -7.5 best performance for a while, thank god Beech has seen he can’t play holding midfield on his own and moved him forward.

Guy-7 difficult for the lad, made a few good runs we were slow to realise, will become a vital players when we get used to playing with him.

Thomas -7.5 with a player like him, you expect him to make at least one big goal scoring chance every game and he did that (mckirdy miss). Tracking back has been a marked improvement under beech v Pressley.

Mckirdy -4 just crap, yes we can argue about the injury etc - but that come from him overrunning the ball. Missed an absolute sitter from some excellent play by Thomas to open them up.

Alessandra -5.5 just wasn’t at the races today - looked a lot better when Patrick come on. Worry if we’re going to play him as a lone striker though as he offered little if anything.

Patrick - 7 steady debut couple of nice touches, already offers more than loft as he’ll run around.

Bridge: 6 as someone said earlier won a few tackles, only problem is he gave the ball back.

Charters - not on long enough.

On the whole a very good performance, nice to see us getting 2nd balls etc.., hopefully a CB, keep Thomas, GK and a winger + CF and this 11 will be decent next season.
The following user(s) Liked this post:: lbtufty

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
09 Feb 2020 10:39 #17 by flumeblue
Replied by flumeblue on topic Player ratings Swindon at home
He didn't re-enter the field of play, he never left as the game re-started. Perhaps the referee should have waited until he was off the pitch.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
09 Feb 2020 11:00 #18 by Bumble
Replied by Bumble on topic Player ratings Swindon at home
Probarbly the best performance I've seen from that ref, which says everything about his usual standard, definitely on the list.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
09 Feb 2020 11:44 #19 by Markovitch
Replied by Markovitch on topic Player ratings Swindon at home
With the exception of the goal which looked a right arse up, I thought the defence was excellent yesterday. Hayden and Webster never gave Yates or Doyle a sniff. Gethin kept Hope quiet and nothing came through Anderton. The 2 Swindon midfielders Grant and Jaiyesime looked very good, Jones, Guy and Watt were never able to really dominate them, Watt was probably the best of the three for me. Upfront we were crying out for a number 9. Allessandra puts in a shift but he's not a centre forward.

Omari looked ok when he came on. Not immediate quality but quick and willing to run, we had more of a threat with him than Alessandra.

Jack Bridge, resplendent with a man bun, not good enough. Symptomatic that the bench is not strong enough that Beech can bring on players who will change things. Our 1-year contract policy will yield benefits in the summer when Iredale, KP, Bridge and friends disappear off.

There was an argument that we were the better team yesterday. If we weren't we matched them in most areas, it certainly wasn't a lucky draw where we nicked a point. Credit to them for going for the win as well. Play like that as there is no doubt we will not go down, and lets cast the crap that was Stephen Pressley behind us. Sadly we probably have to be ready for the fact that Hayden will off to a bigger club in the summer, another game, another man of the match, the best player on the park for me. Got to be scouts watching

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
09 Feb 2020 11:55 #20 by Laffy
Replied by Laffy on topic Player ratings Swindon at home
Agreed

It was interesting that nobody took a blind bit of interest when McKirdy was shouting for his daddy(twice)-and maybe he should pull his socks up if he wants to avoid scratches.

We looked like a football team yesterday-it was a joy to watch after being subjected to dross by Pressley.Charters could well get a run out as he looked confident, relaxed and slotted in without looking overawed.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
09 Feb 2020 12:03 #21 by pacirv
Replied by pacirv on topic Player ratings Swindon at home
Whatever Beech's problem is with Sagaf I really hope he doesn't let him go,the lad has shown enough to suggest he could be a big asset to us if he's given a chance.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
09 Feb 2020 12:08 #22 by seesaw50
Replied by seesaw50 on topic Player ratings Swindon at home

thetashkentterror wrote: McKirdy should have been booked for re-entering the field of play without the referee's permission.


Oh come on....so their guy should have left the field for the first over the top tackle on McKirdy just outside the 18 yard box....this ref, Salisbury is sent here too often he's getting complacent

To have been born Cumbrian
is to have won the lottery of life !

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
09 Feb 2020 12:23 #23 by Zebby
Replied by Zebby on topic Player ratings Swindon at home

pacirv wrote: Whatever Beech's problem is with Sagaf I really hope he doesn't let him go,the lad has shown enough to suggest he could be a big asset to us if he's given a chance.


Beech has sorted this mess out and turned us into a competent team he's coached long enough at a club that punch above their weight to know a decent player and what he wants them to do .
I would suggest all Beech wants Sagaf and others to do is pull their tripe out and bust a gut in training and all these midweek afternoon games and maybe take one of those games by scruff of neck and displace someone in Thier position.

Is he doing that ?

Be just and fear not
The following user(s) Liked this post:: Micktaitwasard

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
09 Feb 2020 13:39 #24 by Goldschmidt
Replied by Goldschmidt on topic Player ratings Swindon at home

seesaw50 wrote:

thetashkentterror wrote: McKirdy should have been booked for re-entering the field of play without the referee's permission.


Oh come on....so their guy should have left the field for the first over the top tackle on McKirdy just outside the 18 yard box....this ref, Salisbury is sent here too often he's getting complacent


The last time he refereed at Brunton Park was October 1st 2016 (2-0 win over Colchester), he booked only 1 Colchester player.
I wouldn't say he's here too often or is complacent at all.
He's definitely not the worst ref in the league.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
09 Feb 2020 13:40 #25 by Seekaye
Replied by Seekaye on topic Player ratings Swindon at home
Couple of digs at Bridge on here, I thought he did well when he came on. He put in one brilliant cross which could’ve won us the game with a bit more luck. He also did well in the Forest Green game
The following user(s) Liked this post:: seesaw50

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
09 Feb 2020 17:16 #26 by Markovitch
Replied by Markovitch on topic Player ratings Swindon at home
Looking forward to Tuesday

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
09 Feb 2020 17:25 #27 by bluebry
Replied by bluebry on topic Player ratings Swindon at home
I think that we all have to remember the referee was bloody Graham Salisbury, he's never ever had a good game when he's reffed us.
The following user(s) Liked this post:: seesaw50

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
09 Feb 2020 20:30 #28 by franksidebottom
Replied by franksidebottom on topic Player ratings Swindon at home

CUFC52 wrote: Never going to get a foul in Anderton for the goal he started shirt pulling/ pushing first.

Colin-6 sketchy at coming for crosses, goal kicks are awful.

G Jones - 8 let’s give him some credit out, him and Anderton have pocketed (Yates and Hope - Jerry is the 4th highest scorer in the leauge)

Hayden -8 is their anything this lad won’t head ? Pleasing thing is he seems to be learning too, seems to of cut out the rash challenges.

Webster 7.5 would of been an 8 if not for his part in the goal, once the man wins it v Anderton - Byron has switched off (again) and left his man, other than that his best performance at Carlisle.

Anderton- 7 imo never a foul for their goal, his passing was very wasteful first 30, but he’s a marked improvement on Ierdale.

Watt - 6.5 the fact you could argue that was his worst performance for Carlisle, shows the lads ability. Grew into the game but was off the pace early on.

M Jones -7.5 best performance for a while, thank god Beech has seen he can’t play holding midfield on his own and moved him forward.

Guy-7 difficult for the lad, made a few good runs we were slow to realise, will become a vital players when we get used to playing with him.

Thomas -7.5 with a player like him, you expect him to make at least one big goal scoring chance every game and he did that (mckirdy miss). Tracking back has been a marked improvement under beech v Pressley.

Mckirdy -4 just crap, yes we can argue about the injury etc - but that come from him overrunning the ball. Missed an absolute sitter from some excellent play by Thomas to open them up.

Alessandra -5.5 just wasn’t at the races today - looked a lot better when Patrick come on. Worry if we’re going to play him as a lone striker though as he offered little if anything.

Patrick - 7 steady debut couple of nice touches, already offers more than loft as he’ll run around.

Bridge: 6 as someone said earlier won a few tackles, only problem is he gave the ball back.

Charters - not on long enough.

On the whole a very good performance, nice to see us getting 2nd balls etc.., hopefully a CB, keep Thomas, GK and a winger + CF and this 11 will be decent next season.


Behave CUFC52, I know you don’t like Webster but to mark him down for his part in the goal is laughable. Anderton is the culprit, muscled off the ball far too easily and it was his man who eventually scored. Even if Webster has been touch tight to his man he still wouldn’t have won the header as it went straight to the blokes head from a couple of yards away.

“Yeah, I know of Barry. Bit of a fantasist” - John Courtenay 2003
The following user(s) Liked this post:: flumeblue

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Time to create page: 0.316 seconds
Website and all content © Copyright 2020 TheCumbrians.net. All Rights Reserved.