-
Forum
-
TheCumbrians.Net
-
Main Forum
-
The Worst Defender We Have Had In Recent Years....
The Worst Defender We Have Had In Recent Years....
-
munchymagic
-
Topic Author
-
Away
-
First Team Player
-
Less
More
-
Posts: 1968
-
Likes received: 675
-
-
31 May 2025 18:53 #1
by munchymagic
I will go for the obvious choice in Mike Edwards, came on big money and had a fairly decent pedigree and was pants.
While we moan at our defence last season with Edwards in the team the opposition had a three goal start usually.
When Aspatria gave him the runaround then it was time to go, I believe he is still stealing a wage at Notts County and just like us he was instrumental in their downfall.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Less
More
-
Posts: 5192
-
Likes received: 1772
-
-
-
-
31 May 2025 18:58 #2
by CCU
Recent years? So say 2000 onwards?
Edwards not even in the top 5!
How about John Inglis, Phil Gulliver, Des Byrne, Paul Warhurst and Shaun Smith?!
Early 00's dross the lot of em...
Win or Lose, Up The Blues!
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Less
More
-
Posts: 224
-
Likes received: 113
-
-
31 May 2025 19:24 #3
by Champions95
Harsh on Warhurst. Played one game (on as a sub, if I remember correctly). Can win the award for 'Most disappointing signing' hands down but didn't have time to be called dross!
My vote would be for David Beharall.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Less
More
-
Posts: 1490
-
Likes received: 840
-
-
Less
More
-
Posts: 2867
-
Likes received: 942
-
-
31 May 2025 19:45 #5
by crunchblue
I class recent years as last 5 or 6 years, so Mike Edwards by a country mile.
There are players who've played one game for us, but it's hard to make a fair judgement on one game... where as Edwards was consistently shite for us.
That defence that Abbott put together at the start of the 13/14 season, with Edwards at the heart of it, is the worst defence I've ever seen and there have been some bad ones! The games we lost 4 and 5 flattered us, and if it wasn't for some poor finishing and great goalkeeping we would have deservedly conceded double figures in each of those matches.
The following user(s) Liked this post:: cufcmike, munchymagic
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Less
More
-
Posts: 571
-
Likes received: 301
-
-
31 May 2025 19:51 #6
by heilkmoon
Kevin Feely was the worst loanee of the Abbott omnishambles defence.
Mike Edwards was a disastrous signing as outlined by crunchblue.
David Beharall's ineptness over a sustained period made him one of the most unpopular players since Kevin Rose.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Less
More
-
Posts: 75
-
Likes received: 11
-
-
-
-
31 May 2025 21:14 #7
by Goldschmidt
What was the name of that Italian left back from about 5 years ago, we gave him a 2 year contract. Think he played twice, then left by mutual consent.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Less
More
-
Posts: 1110
-
Likes received: 394
-
-
31 May 2025 21:17 #8
by Bruntonpasty
Goldschmidt wrote: What was the name of that Italian left back from about 5 years ago, we gave him a 2 year contract. Think he played twice, then left by mutual consent.
Bugno?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Less
More
-
Posts: 177
-
Likes received: 31
-
-
Less
More
-
Posts: 935
-
Likes received: 230
-
-
31 May 2025 21:27 #10
by carwash
The worst defending performance I can recall was by Josh Gowling. He had signed a 2 year contract for us, he played 4 times then was sent out on loan for the rest of his contract he was considered to be that bad.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
-
cousinscotty
-
-
Offline
-
Youth Team Player
-
Less
More
-
Posts: 374
-
Likes received: 116
-
-
-
-
31 May 2025 21:30 #11
by cousinscotty
Robbo wrote: Jeremy corbyn
Isn't he a left winger? I seem to recall the he can't remember what number he is and other relevant figures...
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Less
More
-
Posts: 29
-
Likes received: 9
-
-
Less
More
-
Posts: 62
-
Likes received: 26
-
-
31 May 2025 21:51 #13
by Muffter
Darren Kelly. Utter shite. Came in for big money as "the best defender in Ireland." F@&k; me I wouldn't like to see the second best defender in Ireland.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Less
More
-
Posts: 177
-
Likes received: 31
-
-
31 May 2025 21:54 #14
by Robbo
Macduff wrote: Tom Cruise was no top gun
Rip roger Moore ,
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Less
More
-
Posts: 150
-
Likes received: 52
-
-
31 May 2025 22:11 #15
by Swintonblue
Of players who played a decent number of games Mike Edwards is the obvious stand out, likewise Darren Kelly if we're going back that far.
Thanks CCU for dredging up the nightmare that was Shaun Smith (was he on loan from Hull??)
Beherall had a decent game in the play off final IIRC.
As a one off though I can't think of a worse debut (or performance for that matter) than Harry Worley, subbed at ht and should have been sent off beforehand, utter clart.
Didn't see the ridiculous random loanees Abbott brought in before being sacked but I'm guessing Feely, Black and Butterfield weren't up to much
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Less
More
-
Posts: 711
-
Likes received: 300
-
-
31 May 2025 22:16 #16
by lbtufty
Liam Cooper's horror show performance at Peterborough seals his admission to the short list. Hard to believe our side that day featured Ben Marshall, Nahki Wells, Paddy Madden and Harry Arter!
If the world didn't suck, we'd all fall off.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
-
LakesBlue1
-
-
Offline
-
Reserve Squad
-
-
Johncufc. Up the Blues.
Less
More
-
Posts: 849
-
Likes received: 122
-
-
31 May 2025 22:59 #17
by LakesBlue1
Ben Parker in recent time, A lad called Taylor from Blackburn under Roddy Collins?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
-
cousinscotty
-
-
Offline
-
Youth Team Player
-
Less
More
-
Posts: 374
-
Likes received: 116
-
-
-
-
31 May 2025 23:12 #18
by cousinscotty
Miguel Commingues came with a good reputation...
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Less
More
-
Posts: 794
-
Likes received: 161
-
-
31 May 2025 23:43 #19
by Flatcap
The time Roddy Collins played Steve Livingstone at centre back, I thought was the worst.
The following user(s) Liked this post:: Markovitch, Bluebooze79
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
-
Markovitch
-
-
Offline
-
First Team Player
-
Less
More
-
Posts: 1620
-
Likes received: 299
-
-
01 Jun 2025 04:25 #20
by Markovitch
We signed a centre back call Knight (?), he had been so badly injured he walked with a limp. Played once in a 4 3 home defeat to Walsall. His centre back partner was Simon Jeffels
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
-
PaddockRanger
-
-
Offline
-
Reserve Squad
-
Less
More
-
Posts: 659
-
Likes received: 87
-
-
01 Jun 2025 12:21 #21
by PaddockRanger
Markovitch wrote: We signed a centre back call Knight (?), he had been so badly injured he walked with a limp. Played once in a 4 3 home defeat to Walsall. His centre back partner was Simon Jeffels
Was that the season opener where Oghani scored at both ends?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
-
Markovitch
-
-
Offline
-
First Team Player
-
Less
More
-
Posts: 1620
-
Likes received: 299
-
-
01 Jun 2025 13:01 #22
by Markovitch
Aye, that's right. And Rod Mcdonald did the same for Walsall
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Less
More
-
Posts: 1
-
Likes received: 0
-
-
01 Jun 2025 13:19 #23
by capslockoff
Can't have been Jefffels- he was a bit before that time I think
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Less
More
-
Posts: 484
-
Likes received: 220
-
-
01 Jun 2025 13:34 #24
by bluebry
Seem to remember Simon Jeffels himself being absolutely awful, didnt he once get sent off at Burnley for clattering one of their players on the half way line? who incidentally wasn't causing us any problems. Brain dead springs to mind!
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Less
More
-
Posts: 223
-
Likes received: 116
-
-
Less
More
-
Posts: 1135
-
Likes received: 498
-
-
01 Jun 2025 14:57 #26
by MerseysideBlue
Flatcap wrote: The time Roddy Collins played Steve Livingstone at centre back, I thought was the worst.
It was Simpson who did that.
The following user(s) Liked this post:: LakesBlue1
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Less
More
-
Posts: 1490
-
Likes received: 840
-
-
01 Jun 2025 16:03 #27
by ParcelPete
PaddockRanger wrote:
Markovitch wrote: We signed a centre back call Knight (?), he had been so badly injured he walked with a limp. Played once in a 4 3 home defeat to Walsall. His centre back partner was Simon Jeffels
Was that the season opener where Oghani scored at both ends?
Is that a euphemism?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
-
LakesBlue1
-
-
Offline
-
Reserve Squad
-
-
Johncufc. Up the Blues.
Less
More
-
Posts: 849
-
Likes received: 122
-
-
01 Jun 2025 18:13 #28
by LakesBlue1
MerseysideBlue wrote:
Flatcap wrote: The time Roddy Collins played Steve Livingstone at centre back, I thought was the worst.
It was Simpson who did that.
Collins signed him, Livingstone got banned and by the time he was back Collins was gone.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Less
More
-
Posts: 540
-
Likes received: 258
-
-
02 Jun 2025 04:58 #29
by cufcmike
Some horrible names I'd rather forget in this thread. Matt Young was pants I recall? Never rated Paul Thirlwell as a defender, times were dark when he was needed there!
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
-
nobbyblue
-
-
Offline
-
First Team Player
-
Less
More
-
Posts: 1950
-
Likes received: 765
-
-
02 Jun 2025 13:17 #30
by nobbyblue
Rob Bowman was total shite but played well in the Jimmy Glass game so I'll let him off.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
-
Jumpforfun
-
-
Away
-
Reserve Squad
-
Less
More
-
Posts: 650
-
Likes received: 210
-
-
02 Jun 2025 14:06 #31
by Jumpforfun
Young wasn't great but nowhere near as bad as some of these!
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Less
More
-
Posts: 38
-
Likes received: 7
-
-
02 Jun 2025 14:10 #32
by Kaiser Blue
Sean McGinty was absolutely terrible in his short time for someone who came through at United with Paul Pogba. Changed his boots 4 times one day. Some of Abbott's loanees were utterly awful - Paul Black, Ben Pearson, Kevin Feely... dark times.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Less
More
-
Posts: 848
-
Likes received: 187
-
-
02 Jun 2025 14:24 #33
by Happyblue
cousinscotty wrote:
Robbo wrote: Jeremy corbyn
Isn't he a left winger? I seem to recall the he can't remember what number he is and other relevant figures...
Still was better then the right winger , never turns up and every time they attacked would quickly make a U-turn
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Less
More
-
Posts: 1652
-
Likes received: 686
-
-
-
-
04 Jun 2025 16:57 #34
by Wukkie
I can't believe Pascal Chimbonda hasn't been mentioned yet. People only rated him because he had a 'name'. He should've stayed at Market Drayton Town..
The following user(s) Liked this post:: markredfox73
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
-
markredfox73
-
-
Offline
-
First Team Player
-
Less
More
-
Posts: 2155
-
Likes received: 918
-
-
-
-
05 Jun 2025 10:52 #35
by markredfox73
Agreed ...He tried to make himself look busy waving arms at others when his own positional sense was abysmally shite
Sent from my SM-J320FN using Tapatalk
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
-
LakesBlue1
-
-
Offline
-
Reserve Squad
-
-
Johncufc. Up the Blues.
Less
More
-
Posts: 849
-
Likes received: 122
-
-
05 Jun 2025 11:37 #36
by LakesBlue1
I always thought Chimbonda would have been better suited to a holding midfield role because his legs had totally gone and i don't think he was anywhere near strong enough to be a centre half.
Sean McGinty played about 3 minutes for us.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
-
triskelionblue
-
-
Offline
-
Youth Team Player
-
Less
More
-
Posts: 252
-
Likes received: 90
-
-
05 Jun 2025 12:26 #37
by triskelionblue
I saw Mike Edwards play in a pre-season friendly at Annan. Totally embarrassing.
The following user(s) Liked this post:: munchymagic, LakesBlue1
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
-
Forum
-
TheCumbrians.Net
-
Main Forum
-
The Worst Defender We Have Had In Recent Years....
Time to create page: 0.442 seconds
