walwynlegend wrote:
Northumbrian as I've said in other threads defensively the problem is the wing backs don't come back so especially at 2 nil up that should have changed or go to a flat back 4 so you're right the tactics were risky to put it mildly.
I don't think he got his team selection too far wrong as Troy was injured and so was Atkinson and after Miller's leap and header for the goal you can't say he's weak in the air despite not being tall ( We could have done with a Dean Walling in there who wasn't tall). So the only alternative was a Youth team player unlikely to be strong enough or CMW who seems out of the picture due to attitude.
One thing we all agree on is Raynes needs someone within 20 yards of him to share the burden of challenging or to cover behind when he does.
I thought Miller was weak in the air generally, other than his goal from a set piece... but even Michael Owen scored headers from set pieces. I don't think he is terrible in the air, but those forwards had him and Grainger on toast when it came to winning headers. Curle is playing the continental version of wing backs, where the wings backs don't really defend at all, and are really just wide midfielders.... the wide centre backs are really full backs and the defensive midfielder, Joyce is supposed to drop back into the back 3 when we lose the ball. Nothing wrong with that if you play the right type of players. BUT as you say, we have injuries and that formation really did not fit the way Barnet played. That is where he got it wrong for me. As soon as Barnet got on top with the direct approach we should have switched to a back four to provide some support for Raynes. Tactically it was wrong. He needs to get over his problems with CMW as it is ridiculous that we had no cover on the bench... what would have happened if Raynes was injured in the first minute? Who would have played as the lone centre back? Having said that if he gets a couple of centre backs in then the formation works fine... not with the players we have available currently though.