A Thread for debating who’ll be next into the Brunton Park hotseat!
Admin.
Admin.
Rumour? Co-incidence? Unrelated?
Paul Simpson leaves Bristol City
— The Exiled Robin (@TheExiledRobin) October 22, 2025
Keith Hill... Not a fan, JohnMc?
Interested in your thoughts?
I wouldn't be against it TBH... But, don't know too much, other than looking at his previous record
Turns on players and fans everywhere he goes. A poisonous individual
I'm with JohnMc.
Bringing in Beech's mentor isn't the answer.
Kieth Hill would be nothing short of a disaster the man is more tactically inept than beech
Can't believe people are wanting Sheridan back. The man dropped us like a stone and has absolutely no loyalty to anyone
I like young upcoming managers but with our league status potentially on the line AGAIN this season I think an appointment of someone with experience who can drag us to safety is what's warranted.
Whoever comes in they've still got to deal with those absolute f&#£wits in charge. They're the real problem, they're like a cancer slowly going about their business destroying our club.
I like young upcoming managers but with our league status potentially on the line AGAIN this season I think an appointment of someone with experience who can drag us to safety is what's warranted.
Whoever comes in they've still got to deal with those absolute f&#£wits in charge. They're the real problem, they're like a cancer slowly going about their business destroying our club.
I wouldn't take Hill after what happened at Tranmere.
By all accounts, the players hated him as he was "too old school", whatever that means, and stopped playing for him.
It's got to have been a pretty awful situation for him to have been sacked on the eve of the play-offs. Is this what we need at our club right now?
By all accounts, the players hated him as he was "too old school", whatever that means, and stopped playing for him.
It's got to have been a pretty awful situation for him to have been sacked on the eve of the play-offs. Is this what we need at our club right now?
Good points, all adds to a decent debate. Just hope they / we get it right this time.
COYB
COYB
Keith Curle - fair play he assembled a good squad.
Shows what an average manager he is that he couldn’t get that group of players promoted even with big bonuses and incentives.
Shows what an average manager he is that he couldn’t get that group of players promoted even with big bonuses and incentives.
Keith Hill... Not a fan, JohnMc?
Interested in your thoughts?
I wouldn't be against it TBH... But, don't know too much, other than looking at his previous record
Turns on players and fans everywhere he goes. A poisonous individual
I don't hold Beech as 'to blame' TBH... Losing your best CB, and then a bloody good full back in the opening weeks is a disaster... Anywhere.
Beech was told to get on with it... Pre-season worthless. Dressing room atmosphere - knackered.
Low and behold, 2nd bottom 10 games in. What do we expect?
Never mind, offering Zanzala less wages than Barrow... The board and their lacky, Holdsworth are to blame.
They have a predicament now... Cheap wage manager and much the same, or take the bullet and appoint someone who's been there, done it, knows the score, but who they can't control and wants to spend cash to solve the issues they created in the first place?
Shambles.
Beech was told to get on with it... Pre-season worthless. Dressing room atmosphere - knackered.
Low and behold, 2nd bottom 10 games in. What do we expect?
Never mind, offering Zanzala less wages than Barrow... The board and their lacky, Holdsworth are to blame.
They have a predicament now... Cheap wage manager and much the same, or take the bullet and appoint someone who's been there, done it, knows the score, but who they can't control and wants to spend cash to solve the issues they created in the first place?
Shambles.
Let’s face it, whoever comes in is hardly going to have the best CV around and people are always going to find a fault; inexperienced, journeyman, crap style of play, never been promoted, etc, etc.
Personally I like seeing clubs think outside the box a little and look as though they’ve put a bit of work into finding a decent choice, Swansea have always impressed me in this respect. There’s nothing worse than a boring, lazy appointment of a tired old journeyman manager who clubs see as a safe option.
Someone in the ilk of Neil Critchley who Blackpool appointed from Liverpool’s youth set-up would be a good choice, although you could say Beech was of the same manner and that didn’t turn out great.
Personally I like seeing clubs think outside the box a little and look as though they’ve put a bit of work into finding a decent choice, Swansea have always impressed me in this respect. There’s nothing worse than a boring, lazy appointment of a tired old journeyman manager who clubs see as a safe option.
Someone in the ilk of Neil Critchley who Blackpool appointed from Liverpool’s youth set-up would be a good choice, although you could say Beech was of the same manner and that didn’t turn out great.
Keith Hill... Not a fan, JohnMc?
Interested in your thoughts?
I wouldn't be against it TBH... But, don't know too much, other than looking at his previous record
Interested in your thoughts?
I wouldn't be against it TBH... But, don't know too much, other than looking at his previous record
Keith Hill's odds are shortening on BV and Skybet...
An appointment so ill-fitting, short-sighted and grim it is inevitably true.
What a joke these idiots are
Deliberately waiting until after the Oldham game with their fingers crossed that we win so they can take the cheapest option.
Although beating a club in a worse state than we are shouldn't count as making him the right choice.
Although beating a club in a worse state than we are shouldn't count as making him the right choice.
Now we're warming up…
🚨 EXCLUSIVE 🚨
— Football League World (@FootballLeagueW) October 21, 2025
We understand John McGreal has ruled himself out of the running for the vacant manager’s job at Carlisle United. More here 👇https://t.co/27WQcInyT3#CUFC
There are no replies made for this post yet.
Online Users